Welcome to the Poultry Keepers Podcast!
Poultry Keepers Podcast
Poultry Keepers Podcast
Welcome to The Poultry Keepers Podcast, where we Cluck, Chat, and Rule the Roost! One Egg-cellent Episode at a Time!
At The Poultry Keepers Podcast, we’re building a friendly, informative, and inspiring space for today’s small-flock poultry keepers. Whether you're a seasoned pro with decades of experience or just beginning your backyard chicken journey, you’ve found your community. Here, poultry isn’t just a hobby—it’s a way of life. Each episode is packed with practical, science-based information to help you care for your flock with confidence. From hatching eggs and breeding strategies to flock health, nutrition, housing, and show prep—we cover it all with insight and heart. Hosted by Rip Stalvey, Mandelyn Royal, and John Gunterman, our show brings together over 70 years of combined poultry experience. We believe in the power of shared knowledge and the importance of accuracy, offering trusted content for poultry keepers who want to do right by their birds. So pull up a perch and join us each week as we cluck, chat, and rule the roost—one egg-cellent episode at a time. 
Nov. 15, 2026

Are You Choosing Breeding Chickens With Your Head or Your Heart?

Are You Choosing Breeding Chickens With Your Head or Your Heart?
Are You Choosing Breeding Chickens With Your Head or Your Heart?
Poultry Keepers Podcast
Are You Choosing Breeding Chickens With Your Head or Your Heart?

Your favorite chicken might be the first one you notice in the pen. But is it the bird you want shaping your next generation?

In Part 2 of Smart Selection, Rip Stalvey, Mandelyn Royal, and John Gunterman talk through how they choose breeding chickens that fit their flock goals. They share why an early standout can lose its edge as the rest of the hatch matures, what you can learn by handling your birds regularly, and how a few simple notes can help you see whether your flock is improving from one generation to the next.

In this Poultry Keepers 360 Audio Edition, you’ll hear how to:

· Compare birds from the same hatch and give slower-maturing birds time to show what they’ve got.

· Use consistent lighting, a familiar surface, and hands-on checks to get a fair look at each bird.

· Keep track of growth, egg production, and the traits that matter most to your breeding goals.

· Decide which birds to breed when your personal favorite and your flock goals pull you in different directions.

What are the top three traits you’re selecting for in your flock this year? Share them in the comments.


Join our Facebook Groups:

Poultry Keepers 360 - - https://www.facebook.com/groups/354973752688125
Poultry Breeders Nutrition - https://www.facebook.com/groups/4908798409211973


Speaker

Welcome to another episode of the Poultry Keepers Podcast. Today, John Gunnerman, Mandolin Royal, and Rip Stalvey finished their discussion on smart selection tips. So let's get right to it. We'll pick up where we left off last week.

Rip Stalvey

I I think one thing that folks who are fairly new to breeding need to remember is that there's a difference in maturity rates, maturity rates between meat type birds, layer type birds, standard breed type birds. It's not all the same. It's the information on the internet makes it sound like the birds are going to be all mature at 20 weeks and yada yada. And that's just not true. Does not work that way.

John Gunterman

Depends on where they came from.

Speaker 1

Yeah.

Mandelyn Royal

It'll vary within the same breed.

Speaker 1

Oh, absolutely.

Speaker 2

What lines of bloodline? They're going to be a little bit different one to another.

Speaker 1

And the reason is because one breeder is selecting for something, and the other breeder may not be selecting for that same quality. But by spending time with the birds, we can learn within our breed some traits you're going to show earlier, and some are going to wait until much later. They're not all going to be at the same rate.

Speaker 2

And hopefully the breeder you source from is also willing to mentor on the genetics you actually have.

Speaker

Yes.

Speaker 2

Because they have all that information from all the previous generations.

Speaker 1

Definitely. And speaking of having all the information, one thing I would encourage listeners to do is to keep a journal. When you're sitting out and you're observing your birds, make notes. Just jot down what because I guarantee you you're going to forget it if you don't.

Speaker 3

Oh, we're a podcast. You can't see the binoculars that are in my hand and my window overlooking the yard. But the the ABA wings, sorry, leg bands, you really can't see with binoculars. Can't read the numbers. But I do mark my birds with alcohol-based gel food coloring. And they're distinctive out in pasture because they're white birds, and if they're running around with pink plumage or green plumage or blue plumage in a big splash, and like, oh, I know who you are from a distance. Makes a difference. Especially when I've got a hen going over the wire and laying out in the wild, and I want those eggs for several reasons, which we've already covered. Yeah.

Speaker 2

Where you're talking about late maturing bloodlines. We kind of touched on that a little bit, but then also the early bloomers that fade out in quality. Oh man. I have encountered. I've seen that where I pick an early favorite and we go through the duration of growth, and the next thing you know, there's 10 other birds that are better than that one.

Speaker 1

You're exactly right. It's I find that I wind up picking my birds that I keep from that sort of middle group of the flock.

Speaker 2

Yeah, a lot of them turn out.

Speaker 1

Not the real stellar early, early bloomers, early matures, fast growers, and not the ne'er do wells over here, but those in the middle of the flock tend to give me the most consistency down the road. Sure.

Speaker 3

And if you take that weekly growth or daily weight data on each bird and chart it in a bell curve, you're going to know exactly where the center of your flock is, and you'll be able to make your selection from the middle of that bell curve. At three weeks. And there's a lot of consistency to their later growth rate based upon their early growth rate. It's almost an exact mirror just in large. It's pretty cool.

Speaker 1

And you can't take too many notes. The more information you have, the better decisions you can make.

Speaker 2

Very true.

Speaker 3

And we've talked about doing this criteria on a cohort basis. Having birds of the same age together, even a week different in hatch date can make a difference later on down the line. And there are times where I do band wing band everybody with a different color wing band based upon hatch. And eventually I will take the slower maturing birds and throw them in a week or two back. You're being held back in first or second grade to develop a little bit more. Because they're not ready. I know who they are, and they've already been disqualified. But they're still going to make maybe a good layer or maybe a good meal. But I'm not going to breed with them because the development wasn't right. And I'm going to look at who the parents were and go, Do you constantly throw birds that do this? Or is it on a 10% basis, 50% basis? Maybe I don't want to breed with you two as a pair anymore.

Speaker 1

By consistently observing your birds, making notes, and studying those notes, you're going to be able to spot when your line is starting to drift away from the breed standard. Happen. I promise you. They'll drift on you from year to year.

Speaker 2

I'm going through that now. You know that little saying of never ever mate extremes. Also, I did some dabbling. Proved theory. As it turns out, don't do that because they compound on themselves and hit stronger that next generation. And the next thing you know, you just heterosis is great.

Speaker 3

No, the heterosis is great, the hybrid vigor.

Speaker 2

But by the time you go full circle with it, it's a full two years you've wasted on that scientific experimentation. So I'm glad I got it out of my system.

Speaker 3

But also you got to see Punnett Square in action. There it is.

Speaker 2

And it tickled my little peanut brain, which is great. And I'm glad to be past it.

Speaker 1

But it's good that you did that now and not four or five years further down the road.

Speaker 2

Now I can really confidently say any outside cross you do, whether it's into a different genetic family within the same breed or a complete outcross into whatever, know that you're gonna bring a potential seven years of ramifications by having done that. And some of them aren't gonna become apparent until you've already spent generations. This is not quick, fast, easy stuff. This is compounding generation to generation and adding that diversity to see your genetic persuasions and what all is in there. Know that you're not making as good a progress as you could have made by doing a different approach. You're not gonna reinvent the wheel, you're just gonna learn a whole bunch on how those traits actually move forward through the flock and which things will skip a generation or two.

Speaker 1

Definitely one thing I want to talk about, and Mandelin, you and John are really good at this, is when you evaluate your birds, y'all evaluate them peer-to-peer.

Speaker 2

It's the only way same hatch, same age, same type.

Speaker 1

When Mandelin, I you're probably as thorough as anybody I know, but how do you do that? What's what's your thought processes when you go through that?

Speaker 2

So a lot of people seem to get hung up on what am I basing my decisions on? What's my example? So to streamline it and make it easier on myself, I don't agonize over which bird I'm going to do first. I walk into a pen, I review that pen, and I try to find my favorite visually while observing. So when I pick that bird up and I handle to confirm what I think I saw, that bird will become like my baseline bird. Every bird I pick up after that is either better, the same, or worse. So there's a reason my sort cage has three holes. Those three holes let me go good, better, best. Wonky to not so wonky to pretty okay. It depends on the badge and that breeding behind them and what they're showing me. But being able to rank them into three groups really helps me streamline and then group them and then come up with an assessment of that group. Now, the next group, I'm not comparing them to the group before, just themselves.

Speaker 3

But some other important factors, I think, is your sorting station. You've got everything up at the proper level, you've got good uniform lighting all around. I that that was one of the things that impressed me the most about the time I was able to visit your farm.

Speaker 2

Well, and I have L in a notepad, and everything's waist height, so I get a good head-on view.

Speaker 3

Everything is there to make the evaluation process as easy as possible on you and on the birds. Where I've experienced this, my birds actually look forward, they'll jump up on the scale and pose for me.

Speaker 2

With routine, they make it pretty easy.

Speaker 3

They do, they do, and I can go through and see. The shilling photos are great for that for a fluffy bird. Because you've got a general silhouette, but it still requires hands-on to make sure what's under there is being telegraphed out in the plumage.

Speaker 1

And you talked about is there anything that you two use that could be a tip for our listeners when you're doing your peer-to-peer selection? Like make sure you're using consistent lighting. Even the surface can make a difference.

Speaker 3

Right from the beginning, straight down on the head from hatch. What's their skull width? How do their eyes set?

Speaker 2

Having them at waist height really makes a big difference. Like, I I can host my own chicken show in my own barn every day if I wanted to.

Speaker 3

I do, pretty much. The other thing on lighting, and I know I've talked about this before, is making sure it's a flicker-free light source, and you can check it very easily by using your digital camera on any pocket device and recording in slow motion and playing it back. If you see a strobe, your lights are doing that to your chickens. It's so fast we can't see it happening, but it stresses the birds. Stress them out. It does. Nice subdued beyond. So you don't want an open flame in your barn, and you can't really get incandescent bulbs anymore, but you can get flicker-free bulbs, and I do recommend that. And it's not a strong, harsh light either. It's easier on you and your birds.

Speaker 1

One thing that I find is that it's much easier to evaluate your birds if you've been handling them all along as they're growing up. So they're used to that. They're not flipping out and panicking because they're not, this is a whole new situation. Because when birds are stressed or excited, their whole body type changes. Guarantee you.

Speaker 2

Yes, it really does. And that can even include a complete change in their silhouette because when they stress and when they feel on alert, they pull their feathers in tighter. Not their natural carriage, but like when two boys are getting ready to face off, you can watch them. Those feathers pull in and tighten because it's a protective measure. And then they'll stand up taller, they'll stand up on alert, and that's a completely different bird than the relaxed bird.

Speaker 3

Every animal, if you observe them, has a similar pie. Horse horses will stand up with their ears pinned in with canines. They all do it. Everything affects development. Everything affects development.

Speaker 1

Another thing I've noticed, I've seen people who are raising their birds out on range, but they bring them in and they put them in wire bottom cages to try to evaluate them.

Speaker 2

They don't even know how to stand on that surface.

Speaker 1

They don't. It throws them off. It looks like a totally different bird if they're not used to it. And mine are raised done.

Speaker 3

Mine are raised in the hatching time system, so they're always on wire. It's plastic and it's especially shaped plastic. There's a lot of engineering, but it's a lot of plastic. So I try to get them off of that as soon as possible and onto grass and dirt and soil and engaging with the natural environment.

Speaker 2

Now, what method are you guys using to protect yourselves from emotional bias when it comes to picking favorites? Like you're focusing on the bird, not your sentiment, right?

Speaker 3

Yeah.

Speaker 1

You have to.

Speaker 3

I come from a culinary background and then into a agricultural and farming background to feed people. So every bird eventually is going to feed us in some way.

Speaker 1

I think one thing that helped me, Mandelin, was getting my judge's license.

Speaker 2

Oh, that would do it, wouldn't it? Because now you can judge strangers.

Speaker 1

I cannot look at a bird without thinking, okay, this is wrong, that's wrong, yada yada, yada. And then I try, I force myself to do that when I'm evaluating my own bird. I try to go at it from the standpoint that I have never seen that bird before.

Speaker 2

So I'm sometimes I have to spend an extra day on my selection to make sure the choices I made were the right one.

Speaker 1

Yeah, that's normal. That's normal.

Speaker 3

Sure. And we've got it until week 16 or 18. And I've actually found by holding things over, and some birds are ready to harvest early. And I know where they've reached a point where they're not going to be putting on any more usable meat in relation to feeding them more. They could come out at 16 weeks. And there's some birds that they're out of breeding potential, but they may need to go to 18 weeks because they're still putting on mass in relation to the amount of food going in versus coming out. Some of my set on a processing date. I've got like processing toll gates, so to speak. But it's about efficiency. Mine's all based on I have a finite income and I need to make that work to feed myself. I feed my birds and feed myself in the process. It's just like going to the grocery store and looking at prices on the shelves. It wasn't until I figured out that I was losing money by trying to save money feeding my chickens. But that's a podcast. Yeah, that we talked about that ad nauseum. Garbage in, garbage out. We've all heard that before. But it's true. You let them express their maximum potential, and it's just it's the symbiotic relationship that works. And it's how it has worked for tens of thousands of years.

Speaker 1

Mandelyn said something earlier, and I want to say it again because I think it's important. And that is she doesn't rank her birds keeper or co. It's not an either-or situation with her. Variable. It's one, two, three. Good, better, best. Or not so good, but better and best.

Speaker 3

And we won't settle till our better is best. How's that say? But that's really what it's about. It's about improving the overall quality of your flock.

Speaker 2

My words, birds, come from my most diverse genetics. Imagine that.

Speaker 3

Ironic how that happens. So when are you making that big jump from pen mating to pedigree mating?

Speaker 2

When I have sourced a fleet of appropriate size cages to organize it pen by pen. It would be a $1,500 investment.

Speaker 1

Madeline, I'm working on something that could solve your problem.

Speaker 2

I'm working on a design for a pair mating pasture tractor, but we've got to get the material for the prototype. It'll hold eight females, one male out on pasture with a slide door system for exposure and egg collection by the hen, so I can label it by the hen as it comes out, but that prototype we haven't built yet.

Speaker 1

Have designed a trap nest front.

Speaker 3

Retrofit onto any nest box standard size opening. Yeah.

Speaker 1

It's very simple to use. It's basically just a three-part system.

Speaker 2

But then you have to go retrieve. Do you need a nest box for each hen then? No, no.

Speaker 3

No, once you go and let them out and collect their egg, it's reset for the next ten. So if you have a row of them, naturally what's going to happen is they're all going to get stuck. Hopefully, not in the same box. Because they do like to pile.

Speaker 1

You can't overdo the box size, that's for sure. I'd rather you you may need a deeper box, but not a wider box. And I say deeper box is because when the hen lays her egg, she will come to the front of the box. There's a gate there that she can't get out of, but she's moving to the light, that's normal. And if she's standing in where the eggs are, she could break an egg. So you want to give them up a little more depth to work with.

Speaker 2

So my thought was because I like to use really fresh hatching eggs, seven days old, no more. So if I remove hens from their home pen and put them somewhere else, they might stress out and quit laying.

Speaker

Yeah, they gotta be used to this.

Speaker 2

If I had a tower inside of their home pen and made it a matter of routine to where let's say I had a stack of three cages with automatic water, feed cups, everything, they are adequately equipped to stay there for six days because I expect five to six eggs a week from my girls. Yes. So then by doing that, I know their daily rate for those hens I put in there. I like my pens to have less than the number of birds that could fit. So my pens can fit up to 15, but for management and cleanliness, I prefer 10 or less. So nine females, one male, three females in hatching collection, and rotate that. So three hens go in, and then at the end of the week, I swap them for a different set of three, and it becomes a matter of their routine in theory.

Speaker 3

And anybody who doesn't lay five eggs on their past to come back.

Speaker 2

They just come out of the team.

Speaker 3

Yeah, I would say without knowing what your daily production for each hen is, that's critical to know.

Speaker 2

But then it's set up on a weekly rotation, which makes my life easier.

Speaker 3

Yes. Yeah. If you get with three hens, I can tell the difference between my five hens when I'm collecting some. But each egg, I know which hand laid that egg now just by looking at it and feeling it and going, oh yeah, I sir. Because they're like fingerprints to me.

Speaker 1

Even the egg smells. Let's talk about flock goals and the selection process.

Speaker 2

Basically, we're waiting on the flock to tell us what is and isn't working.

Speaker 1

Yeah, exactly. Yeah. But before you even put birds in a cage to start evaluating them, ask yourself, what's your goal for this group of birds? Are you looking for egg layers? Are you looking for meat birds? Show birds? Do you want birds with broody tendencies or not? You know what do you expect from this group of birds?

Speaker 3

That should be fall in line with your overall flock goals. Yeah.

Speaker 2

And then you go digging through that flock looking for the birds who meet your standards that hopefully also reflect their breed standards.

Speaker 3

Exactly. And the more you do it, the more it's gonna self-repeat and it'll become a self-fulfilling prophecy, and the world will be a beautiful place.

Speaker 1

Let's talk about tools and tips and techniques that we've used that makes for a better evaluation. For example, when I'm doing it, I want a clipboard. I used to use a camera, but now I've got my cell phone. I use that. I usually print out a spreadsheet and I can make notes on that spreadsheet, and then I can enter it into the computer at a later time. And the other thing that I have found handy for me, works well for what I do, is some various colored leg bands.

Speaker 3

Oh, leg bands, wing bands. That's you've got to start there. You've got to differentiate them permanently. Something else you didn't mention that I do want to bring up, which was a great investment, is a plastic caliper, vernier caliper scale. It doesn't matter what the scale is. In fact, I've got a couple different colored ones, and I put some masking tape around the handle. So if I'm like measuring skull width, I got a go, no-go gauge. I've got a green one and a red one. Anyone that's bigger than this size goes over here, and everybody that's smaller than this size goes over here. But because it's plastic, you're not going to hurt it. It's less than a dollar. But if, you know, actually measuring chest width, you know, the pick the point between the shoulder blades and put your caliper there. And there's a number. It is no longer subjective. If you're one of these people that don't trust your highly calibrated fingers and eyeballs, you should, because they are very highly calibrated. You've got a non-objective thing that costs you less than a dollar.

Speaker 1

John, something I'd use those for too is to gauge feather width on my birds.

Speaker 3

Yes. And shaft diameter.

Speaker 2

I wonder how many people actually get into those wings and actually look at the width of the individual feathers. There are I didn't start doing that until three. Years ago.

Speaker 3

Not very many. Those are the real sh, I mean, real persnickity breeders, the super showers. I want to get some of them on here to talk about their ticket.

Speaker 1

That's the people that have learned a value in paying attention to the little bitty details. Attention to detail. Because they're not going to be able to do that.

Speaker 2

No, when I use my thumb to check the back of the skull with I count the lines on my knuckle.

Speaker 3

But it's a comparison and it's in a cohort. They're all the same age, so they should be at the same level of development. So having a clear indicator of good, better, best. Medium, average, too big, too small, whatever you want to call it, you have a differentiator that's always at hand. Therefore, your hand. But it's these cheap, they're disposable, they're plastic. You can throw them in the dishwasher, whatever.

Speaker 1

No matter what the tool is, use it over and over. Doesn't matter whether it's John's caliper or Mandy using her thumb. As long as she uses it consistently, year after year, she's gonna make progress.

Speaker 2

Peer against peer. They're either better or worse than the bird you handled before.

Speaker 3

And it's this year, this particular grow out, this particular hatch. And then you can all going to be slightly different.

Speaker 2

Because your notes let you know next year if you made progress or not.

Speaker 3

Whoo we're getting fired up.

Speaker 2

I'm living the life right now by just being in the middle of grow out season. Like I'm sorting birds weekly.

Speaker 3

And the scale is critical. If you don't have a scale, you need one.

Speaker 1

One thing I had to go through early on, and it was very hard to break myself. And it was something I call the collector's curse. And I felt like I needed to keep every bird possible. That's the quickest way I know to fail.

Speaker 3

You think they're gonna show you something at the very end, but really they're not, if they've already showed you that they're not. The outstanding bird's going to be outstanding its entire lifespan.

Speaker 1

And folks, it's okay if your goals are different than somebody else's. They don't have to be identical. Okay. Because what I look at, Mandolin and John may not give it a second thought. And vice versa. So it's okay to have different goals. That makes sense. Them right and you wrong. It just makes it different. That's all it is. Different.

Speaker 3

My Chanticlair would be miserable in Florida. They don't have a comb or a wattle to shed heat.

Speaker 2

They're a little miserable in Ohio, and summers got trickier with adding that new group.

Speaker 3

And they're miserable here when it gets above 80. They just seem to melt into puddles in the ground.

Speaker 2

But man, can they lay in the winter? Yeah.

Speaker 3

That's what they're designed for.

Speaker 2

So when my breasts are taken off the winter, those chanticleer fire up. And in the summertime, when the chanticleer gets lazy and don't really want to lay that much, my breasts are still laying. So between the two different types, I get year-round eggs more so than just having different ages in my flock.

Speaker 3

But you you can do that by doing fall hatches for spring production and spring hatches for fall production for eggs, which we have talked about. But that brings up a really good point about regionalities. I was talking with somebody at an event last week, and I told them to look you up, Rip, because you would at least be a good resource. They live down in Southwest Florida, and they're like, what breed should I get? Like, you should really find somebody local or somebody that has some stock that's been adapted to that area. Find who's got some birds that are doing well and somebody that's interested in helping you get started and start there. Don't start with importing hatching eggs or birds from Alaska or he really wanted Rhode Island Ritz. So I'm like, ooh, my friend Rip. That's a good George. He's probably not interested in selling any of his birds, but he could probably hook you up with somebody who has some really good quality stock that's not too far away from you, that's used to the feed and water and conditions that you are raising in and can inform you towards somebody that's gonna fall in line with your goals as well.

Speaker 1

There's something I want to mention, and we just published our 114th episode, I believe. And I think we probably mentioned it just about every show, maybe not every show, but almost every show, is that handle your bird regularly. It's gonna develop your hands and your eyes to work together to determine what's going on with your bird's body.

Speaker 2

And I think it helps to spend time learning what does make them different from each other. Because finding those differences helps you see who is the stronger one, who is the biggest one, who is the widest, who's the most like just look for those differences before you look at those similarities because you can get lost in the similarities, you can get flock blind pretty quick, especially if they're all the same breed. What is making them different on an individual basis? Because those differences are your selection point. That's what you're choosing, or not.

Speaker 3

That's where I want to get to a show, actually. I want to see a lot of birds that are representative of a specific type on display so I can actually look at the differences and see them displayed, see it from the judge's perspective.

Speaker 2

And then go cruise champion row. What made those birds similar? What made the winner?

Speaker 3

Or what got them there that day? Going to a show, even if you don't ever planning plan on showing, can be amazingly informative and educational and great for building the community, camaraderie, the flocks in general, and when the flock in general, I mean our planet, so to speak.

Speaker 1

And when you're doing selection, folks, you got to remove the emotion from it. Select with attention, not emotion. Every time I have found myself selecting on emotion, I made a mistake. Takes a tough man to make a tender chicken. That's right. Hey, we're at the end of our notes here, but I just want to thank everybody for joining us today. I have I have had fun. I think I've enjoyed this episode about as much as anyone we've ever done, y'all.

Speaker 3

This is really what it's all about. Yeah. Yeah. And this is where we want to put it out to the listeners, too. And we all know the genetics are the blueprint, but we're the builders. We control what goes in and what comes out. What do you want to talk about online? Let's drive some discussion here.

Speaker 1

If you're not a member of our Facebook group, Poultry Keepers Broadcast Facebook groups, you need to be on there. We're posting information there almost daily that we don't talk about here on the show.

Speaker 3

But if you've got some more time there to there's more time for interaction. The feedback would be good for us to gauge where all y'all are at and what you want to hear. Because we can just sit here and talk about chickens and what entertains us all day long. And it seems to be working, but I'd really like to focus in on what the listeners want to hear. Yeah. And the listener flock, we've got a nobody knows everything, but together we know so much. So share some photos of your chicks and your grow outs.

Speaker 2

And maybe what you look for in your flock. What are the traits that are important to you? And what are you steering your flock towards?

Speaker 3

What are your top three selection criteria this year? What are you looking for? If nothing else, it helps to formulate the thought and write it down and put it out there for the world. View it as some level of self-accountability. Nobody's gonna chastise you for it, but you just you're putting it in writing and you're committing to it. And I think that's important. Absolutely. And we're here to help you get there.

Speaker 2

You can change a lot in three generations.

Speaker 1

So before we go, I want to leave y'all with this one statement. Great birds don't happen by accident. They're the result of smart decisions. And with that, thanks for joining us. We've had fun. Thanks for listening, everybody.